Skip to Content

The 35 Best Psychological Thriller Books to Scare Yourself Silly

Don't turn out the lights — these thriller books will haunt your dreams.

By
best psychological thrillers
amazon, walmart

We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

Some of us like to escape with a romance novel, living vicariously through happy couples frolicking off into a beautiful sunset or gettin' steamy afterward. Some like to live vicariously through historical fiction, or think about what it's like to walk in someone else's shoes while reading a revealing memoir. Others tend a bit more toward the macabre — diving into a story that's rife with ghosts and ghouls, murder and mayhem and the kind of creeptastic plots that run through your mind as you lay awake at night. These hair-raising psychological thriller books are perfect for those of us in the last category.

While giants like Stephen King and Agatha Christie usually come to mind when we reach for a suspenseful book, they're definitely not the only ones mastering the genre. Writers like Ruth Ware, Liane Moriarty, Gillian Flynn and Riley Sager are all putting out the kind of thrilling reads that may keep us from being able to sleep through the night ever again. And if ghost stories aren't for you, there's plenty of variation within the thriller category. Whether you like realistic stories about friends or family members gone bad or things that go bump in the night, we bet you can find your next favorite spine-tingling read on this list. Oh, and don't forget to browse our guide to the best books of 2020, if you need a lighter come-down to help get to sleep.

1

Ruth Ware One by One

One by One
Now 68% Off
Credit: courtesy of Gallery/Scout Press

Claustrophobics: beware. If your worst nightmare involves getting stranded in a remote locale with your coworkers, just imagine if people started dying. This suspenseful novel from one of our favorite mystery madames will keep you guessing through the last page. 

RELATED: 20 True Crime Podcasts That’ll Make Your Commute Go by so Fast

2

Alex Michaelides The Silent Patient

The Silent Patient

Alicia is a star painter living a seemingly perfect life. That is, until her fashion photographer husband comes home late one night and she shoots him five times in the face. Alicia never speaks again, and becomes a notorious mystery, which just skyrockets her art to even higher demand. But Theo Faber is determined to get her to talk, and his search for the truth soon gets out of control. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Liane Moriarty Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty

Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty
Credit: G.P. Putnam's Sons

The hit TV show was a riveting book first, so pick it up if you just can't get enough. Three moms find themselves embroiled in tragedy, which may have more to it than immediately meets the eye. Each of them have their own crosses to bear and starkly different lives, but they may harbor the same terrible secret.  

4

A.J. Finn The Woman in the Window: A Novel

The Woman in the Window: A Novel
Credit: William Morrow

Anna Fox is a shut-in who spends her days drinking, watching TV, and spying on the neighbors. She becomes especially enamored with one family across the way. But one day, she sees something shocking, and her entire life (not to mention her carefully kept secrets) all starts to unravel. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Tana French The Searcher: A Novel

The Searcher: A Novel
Now 57% Off
Credit: courtesy of Viking

The latest from one of the greatest mystery novelists writing today takes us to a bucolic Irish village so vivid, I dreamed about it. Retired Chicago cop Cal Hooper moves there to spend his twilight years fixing up his house and fishing, but instead he finds a cagey kid whose brother has gone missing, sheep who keep turning up eviscerated, and a town that's a lot more mysterious than it seems. 

6

Samantha Downing My Lovely Wife

My Lovely Wife
Credit: Penguin Random House

Every marriage has its issues — nobody's perfect. But when one couple starts to feel like their relationship is growing distant, they decide a hobby might help. Then young girls start turning up dead all around town. Is there a connection? You'll have to read this gripping thriller to find out. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Joyce Carol Oates Pursuit

Pursuit
Credit: Mysterious Press

As a child, Abby has a recurring nightmare in which she wanders through a field of human bones. And just before her wedding to Willem, the dream returns with a vengeance. Less than 24 hours before they say "I do," she steps into traffic. As she lies in her hospital bed, Willem must find out whether it was intentional act, and why she keeps waking up screaming. 

8

Joann Chaney As Long as We Both Shall Live: A Novel

As Long as We Both Shall Live: A Novel

When Matt's wife falls to her death while they're hiking, it at first seems like a terrible accident. But his first wife also died under suspicious circumstances. And then another body appears. You might get whiplash from the dark plot twists in this murder mystery about how marriage can go sour. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

Gillian Flynn Gone Girl

Gone Girl

When Amy Dunne disappears on her and her husband Nick's fifth wedding anniversary, everyone's baffled. Nick seems equally shocked, but also starts behaving oddly suspicious. And Amy's diary reveals a dark side that could almost look like motive. As the pressure mounts, Nick starts to crack, but it remains to be seen whether he's seriously stressed or has something to hide.  

10

Cambria Brockman Tell Me Everything: A Novel

Tell Me Everything: A Novel
Credit: Ballantine Books

In her first weeks at Hawthorne College, Malin gets swept into a tight-knit circle of friends, all unique people who fit together perfectly. She's an expert at hiding her dark past, but nobody can hide forever. By Senior Day, everyone’s secrets come out and Malin’s missteps set in motion a chain of events that end in murder. Read to unravel some seriously twisted relationships. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11

Paula Hawkins The Girl on the Train

The Girl on the Train
Credit: Riverhead Books

Commuters may recognize themselves in this chilling story. Rachel takes the same train every day, and every day, she watches the same couple going about their lives as she passes by. But one day, she sees something horrible. And before she can say "one MetroCard swipe," she's embroiled in an investigation. Read this one before watching the hit film

12

Silvia Moreno-Garcia Mexican Gothic

Mexican Gothic
Now 48% Off
Credit: courtesy of Del Rey Books

This one's worth reading for the setting alone, as Noemí Taboada gets a frantic letter from her recently married cousin summoning her to save her from a remote mansion in the Mexican countryside. The house is just as creepy as it sounds, but the glamorous Noemí also has to contend with its inhabitants and their dark secrets. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13

Helen Phillips The Need

The Need
Credit: Simon & Schuster

Moms know that exhaustion does strange things to your brain. In the wake of insomnia and the anxiety of new motherhood, Molly starts hearing things. Or at least, she thinks she is. This delightfully strange thriller explores the duality of parenthood and the darker side of domesticity in an affecting read that will haunt you. 

14

Fiona Barton The Suspect

The Suspect

This book exploits every parent's nightmare. After two girls go missing while on a gap year in Thailand, journalist Kate Waters is determined to uncover the truth of what happened to them. But she's also distracted by thoughts of her own son, who went radio silent himself while traveling two years ago. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15

Stephen Chbosky Imaginary Friend

Imaginary Friend
Credit: Grand Central Publishing

If you grew up reading Perks of Being a Wallflower, you won't want to miss this one. Kate takes her son Christopher and flees an abusive relationship, and when they land in an idyllic small town, everything seems like it'll be OK. But then Christopher disappears and returns with a compulsion to built a treehouse. If he doesn't complete it by Christmas, the town's residents will pay the price. 

16

Jessica Barry Freefall: A Novel

Freefall: A Novel

A plane crashes, a daughter disappears, and a mother can't believe her child is actually gone. Follow Allison's struggle to get home after the plane crash and her estranged mother Maggie's desperation to discover the truth in this thriller about two women's unbreakable bond, even through unimaginable adversity.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
17

Alyssa Cole When No One Is Watching

When No One Is Watching
Now 46% Off
Credit: courtesy of William Morrow

Gentrification takes a dark turn as Brooklyn native Sydney Green's neighbors start suspiciously disappearing. As she researches the history behind her hometown and uncovers some dark dealings, that background comes terrifyingly close to home. Things really ramp up as she gets closer to the truth, and she might not make it out alive. 

18

Sara Collins The Confessions of Frannie Langton: A Novel

The Confessions of Frannie Langton: A Novel

Travel along with this winding historical thriller as it takes us from a Jamaican sugar plantation to the streets of Georgian London. A servant and former slave stands accused of a gruesome double murder, but can’t remember what happened. As the story unwinds, it also unmasks perpetrators of even greater crimes on a much broader level. 

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19

Simone St. James The Sun Down Motel

The Sun Down Motel
Credit: Berkley

This creepy supernatural thriller will send shivers down your spine. Carly moves to the little town of Fell to suss out what happened when her aunt Viv disappeared from her front desk job at the Sun Down Motel in 1982. She nets the same job, but strange things start happening right away. As she discovers a serial killer preying on women throughout history, things get downright dangerous. 

20

Kirsten Alexander Lost Boy Found (Deckle Edge)

Lost Boy Found (Deckle Edge)

Based on the true story of Bobby Dunbar's mysterious disappearance, this Southern historical novel os about a child who goes missing in 1913 and the two mothers desperate to claim him as their own. Part historical fiction, part suspenseful thriller, this one explores the role of social class in justice, and will make you hug your own little ones extra tight. 

Headshot of Lizz Schumer
Lizz Schumer
Senior Editor
Lizz (she/her) is a senior editor at Good Housekeeping, where she runs the GH Book Club, edits essays and long-form features and writes about pets, books and lifestyle topics. A journalist for almost two decades, she is the author of Biography of a Body and Buffalo Steel. She also teaches journalism as an adjunct professor at New York University's School of Professional Studies and creative nonfiction at the Muse Writing Center, and coaches with the New York Writing Room.
Watch Next 
best psychological thrillers
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below