The 5 Best Fly Swatters, According to Testing
Say goodbye to flying pests with these budget-friendly classics and high-tech zappers.
We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.
Nothing ruins a peaceful evening spent outdoors faster than the persistent buzz of a housefly or a mosquito biting at your ankles. Whether prepping dinner, enjoying your patio, or trying to sleep, sometimes the only way to deal with unwanted insects is the old-fashioned way — with a satisfying swat. The classic wire-handled fly swatter is still effective, but new models include thoughtful updates like extendable handles or built-in zappers. Eliminating bugs is the goal, but there are now more than a few ways to do it, some more fun than others.
The Good Housekeeping Institute has been testing home products for decades, and the basic fly swatter design has remained unchanged for just as long. But there are some innovations in this category that I was excited to test. I evaluated these fly swatters based on their ease of use, price and performance in kitchens, bedrooms and outdoor spaces. Here are the best fly swatters to buy right now for every type of home — and every kind of bug.
Pros
- Adjustable handle length
- Durable swatter head
Cons
- No ring on handle for hanging
The Extendable Fly Swatter solves one of the most frustrating problems when killing flies, reaching those insects that settle just beyond your grasp. From landing on the ceiling to perching at the edge of your kitchen counters, this fly swatter gives you enough reach to smack those buggers.
The standout feature is right in the name. The plastic handle telescopes from standard length to an impressive 28 inches, instantly giving you access to ceiling corners, behind furniture or high wall spaces without dragging out a step stool.
Despite its lightweight construction, this fly swatter delivers surprising durability. The ergonomic handle design with built-in grips is great for extended bug-hunting sessions, while the flexible swatter head offers enough give to prevent breakage but retains its shape when making contact with harder surfaces. It is missing a ring or hole in the handle for easy storage.
If you're looking for an affordable and practical solution to eliminate flying insects, this swatter delivers at a price that makes it easy to keep one in every room.
Pros
- Cheap cost
- Large striking area
Cons
- Swatter head is tough to clean
This six-pack of fly swatters can help you protect your house, patio, garage and RV for around $10. Sometimes the simplest solution is still the most effective as these flyswatters deliver impressive performance without breaking the bank.
The braided metal handles provide the perfect balance of lightweight maneuverability and sturdy construction that I look for in quality tools. Unlike flimsy plastic alternatives that snap after a few vigorous swats, these are built to last through multiple bug seasons. Just make sure to clean it after each swat as bug guts can build up.
If you're tired of chasing flies with rolled-up magazines, this affordable six-pack delivers an impressive bang for your buck and earns my recommendation as the best value for manual pest control.
Pros
- Makes killing bugs fun
- No bug mess
Cons
- Pricey
This unique bug exterminator gamifies the task of killing gnats and flies and turns it into an activity that might have you secretly hoping for more flying invaders.
The concept is simple — load ordinary table salt into the hopper, pump the action, aim and fire at pesky flies from 2-3 feet away. The salt disperses in a pattern that effectively stuns or eliminates soft-bodied insects without chemicals or messy cleanup. No more cleaning off bug guts from your countertop!
During my backyard testing, I found the streamlined design comfortable to hold even during extended bug-hunting sessions. Despite its playful appearance, this isn't a toy and should be handled with care. At nearly $50 the Bug-A-Salt is an investment, but it does come with a one-year warranty.
This unit comes in pink with black accents, but there are a variety of other color combinations to suit your preference.
Eliminator Flexible Bug Zapping Racket
Pros
- Flexible design
- Strong electric shock
Cons
- Slightly heavy
The Eliminator Flexible Bug Zapping Racket is a hands-on solution for homeowners tired of passively waiting for insect traps to work.
At just under 20 inches long and weighing 2 pounds, this battery-powered bug zapper strikes the perfect balance between reach and maneuverability. Unlike traditional fly swatters that require perfect aim, the Eliminator's electrified mesh surface creates a generous strike zone that dispatches insects on contact with a jolt of electricity.
During my testing, this feature proved particularly effective against mosquitoes and gnats that typically require multiple swatting attempts. I swung it through the air over some standing water that was filled with mosquitos, and it crackled with every swing. I tested it with my fingers and received a little jolt that was harmless but would definitely kill a bug. It's weight it can be tough to swat some fast flying insects.
The flexible design allows the racket to bend slightly upon impact rather than breaking — a common failure point in rigid electric swatters. This thoughtful engineering touch means you're less likely to be shopping for a replacement mid-summer.
Pros
- Great length
- Durable construction
Cons
- Clean after each use
These are the quintessential fly swatters that have been protecting American homes for generations, and during my hands-on testing, I found the 21-inch length hits the sweet spot of reach without sacrificing control.
What separates these from bargain bin alternatives is the durable construction. The wire handle provides just enough flexibility to absorb impact without bending permanently, while the plastic swatter head offers enough surface area to improve your hit rate. Make sure you clean it after each use to stop the spread of germs.
The variety pack (with black, red or yellow colors) makes it easy to keep one in the kitchen and one on the patio for quick access when buzzing visitors arrive.
How we test fly swatters
At the Good Housekeeping Institute, our approach to testing fly swatters is all about real-world performance. Whether you're swatting flies in the kitchen or trying to reach a buzzing mosquito on the patio, we evaluate how each swatter handles common household pests in a variety of environments. That includes everything from fast-moving fruit flies to larger, more stubborn bugs like houseflies and wasps.
We pay close attention to how effective each swatter is at actually eliminating insects — not just stunning them. A good swatter should deliver a clean, swift kill with minimal effort, and it shouldn’t require multiple swings to get the job done. For electric models, we test how quickly they zap bugs and if they’re powerful enough to kill them with one swing.
We also assess how easy each swatter is to store and use. Some come with hooks for convenient storage, while others might be bulkier or more awkward to keep nearby. Durability is another factor: we check whether the handle feels sturdy, if the mesh or plastic is prone to bending or breaking, and how well it holds up after repeated use. Lastly, we take cleanliness into account — does the swatter leave a mess behind? Is it easy to wipe down?
What to look for in the best fly swatter
When evaluating fly swatters for this guide, I focused on practical considerations that make a difference to homeowners. An effective and durable fly swatter is what matters most and these characteristics can help you decide.
✔️ Effectiveness: The primary job of any fly swatter is to eliminate pests quickly and reliably. I tested each model against common household insects including flies, mosquitoes, and gnats to evaluate their success rate. The mesh or surface material needs to be substantial enough to dispatch insects on contact but flexible enough to prevent damage to surfaces.
✔️ Durability: A good fly swatter should last through multiple seasons of use. I examined construction quality, paying special attention to common failure points like handle connections and mesh attachments. Products with reinforced components or materials resistant to cracking and warping score higher in my evaluations.
✔️ Ergonomics: Comfort matters during extended use. I assessed handle design, weight distribution, and grip texture across various hand sizes. Models that cause hand fatigue or strain during prolonged use receive lower ratings regardless of their effectiveness.
✔️ Reach and Accessibility: The ability to target insects in hard-to-reach places significantly impacts a swatter's usefulness. I measured each model's effective range, paying particular attention to extendable options.
✔️ Cleanup: After dispatching an insect, removing the remains should be simple and hygienic. I evaluated how easily each swatter can be wiped clean and whether perforated designs allow for easier disposal of insect remains.
✔️ Value: While premium features like electric grids or extended handles may justify higher costs, I looked for models that deliver reliable performance without unnecessary expense. The most expensive option isn't always the best choice for most households.
✔️ Storage Convenience: Practical storage solutions like hanging loops or slim profiles factor into my ratings, as fly swatters should be easily accessible when needed but unobtrusive when not in use.
Through rigorous testing across these criteria, I identified products that offer the best combination of effectiveness, durability, and value.
Why trust Good Housekeeping
This guide was created by writer and editor Timothy Dahl, who covers everything from consumer electronics to home, outdoor tools and more. He lives in a desert climate with a yard full of lush native plants as well as plenty of dog poo that attracts the largest flies you've ever seen, making for a target rich testing ground for swatting flies and insects.
Timothy Dahl is an experienced writer and editor covering home improvement, DIY, and lifestyle topics for nearly 20 years. With a deep background in hands-on testing and reporting, he has reviewed and worked with hundreds of tools, products, and home innovations. Timothy's work has appeared in The New York Times, Wired, and Popular Mechanics, and he's the founder of Charles & Hudson. He specializes in making complex projects accessible and is passionate about empowering homeowners with clear, actionable guidance.
