10 Best Pillow-Top Mattresses, Tested by Experts

A Euro-top mattress, like a pillow-top mattress, provides extra padding but the top lines up with the edges of the mattress for a more uniform appearance. This one feels indulgent and luxurious, like a classic pillow top, cushioning your body in all the right places. Its medium firmness is versatile, and the tall height isn't so tall that you'll need special deep-pocket sheets.

For extra padding and a cool feel, opt for the GlacioTex cooling cover.

Tester notes: Users with different sleeping positions unanimously gave the mattress top scores when it came to comfort. One said, "It feels plush but doesn't feel like it's swallowing me up, and there's just enough bounce that allows me to shift and turn over in the night."

Another liked that it didn't sink in as much as her previous pillow-top mattress. The caveat? While DIY set-up is simple, the bed is heavy and doesn't have handles.

Who it's best for: Combination sleepers who frequently change positions throughout the night, couples who can't agree on a firmness level and anyone who likes a classic pillow-top feel.

Who should avoid it: Those who prefer a plusher firmness should consider Helix's Moonlight Luxe instead. Older users who may not want to set up their own boxed mattress.

Allswell's mattresses continue to impress our experts and testers, delivering quality at lower price points. While mattress prices have fluctuated over the past years, Allswell's pricing has remained consistent, and the Supreme has earned high praise from our testers for its comfortable feel. Though it only comes in one firmness level, this hybrid model has a plush, built-in Euro top for extra cushioning that cradles pressure points.

Tester notes: Our most recent tester of this mattress shared, "my previous mattress did not have a pillow top; you can feel the difference in having the extra layer right away." She also added that it "forms to your body without denting or deflating, even after a long period of using it." Still, the edge support isn't the best compared to our other picks, so those with mobility issues may find it difficult to get out of bed.

Who it's best for: Price-conscious shoppers who are looking to spend under $500. In our tests, this was a favorite among young adults in their 20s.

Who should avoid it: Older users or those with limited mobility may find the edge support and DIY setup unideal.

Serta's Perfect Sleeper is the most commonly purchased model amongst our survey panel for good reason. It has three variations to choose from, plus eight different firmness levels, including one Euro top and three pillow-top options. The mattress will be delivered to your home through a delivery service, and you can opt to pay for full-service setup and mattress removal.

Tester notes: We've received feedback from over 1,000 Serta owners. Owners of this model liked the support but were divided on its longevity. One person who slept on it for over 10 years told us the pillow top has held up well, while another who has had it for 9 years noted the top has noticeably flattened out.

Still, most were happy with their purchase, including one who shared, "I was really pleased with the quality given [the price point]. The pillow top made it really comfortable. It was supportive without feeling firm."

Who it's best for: Shoppers who like to try mattresses in store before purchasing or anyone who likes having a variety of options to choose from.

Who should avoid it: Those who don't want to feel overwhelmed with too many mattress variations and anyone who has consistently had issues with mattress longevity.

A plush pillow-top mattress can help relieve pressure in key areas, like the hips and shoulders, to keep your spine in neutral alignment, which makes it ideal for side sleepers. This option from Beautyrest comes highly recommended from multiple side sleepers on our panel, who highlighted its cushioned pillow top. It has a lofty quilted top with several layers of foam to contour to your body, and, rest assured, it comes with complimentary white-glove delivery.

Tester notes: Over 500 of our panelists (including side sleepers) own a Beautyrest mattress, and many called the tall pillow-top their favorite part of the bed. This model is one of our tallest picks, and some admitted that the height made it difficult to find sheets that fit. One user who owns the plush pillow-top said, "It is soft yet firm enough that you don't sink into the mattress. My body does not ache like it used to on my old one."

Who it's best for: Side sleepers who like the feel of pillow-top mattresses, in-store shoppers and anyone who prefers full-service delivery with setup.

Who should avoid it: Those who run hot at night; our testers found it warmer than similar mattresses.

Many of our panelists, especially those who prefer firmer beds, praised the supportive feel of Stearns & Foster's Estate Collection, thanks to its complex, two-in-one coil system. The Lux Estate offers true indulgence, featuring high-quality, hand-crafted materials including layers of memory foam from Tempur-Pedic for pressure relief. For the pillow-top version, you can choose between three firmness levels.

Tester notes: Many panelists applauded its excellent support over time, and those who opted for the pillow-top style highlighted its comfort. One told us, "you feel like [the mattress] is enveloping you," and another described it as "supportive but still soft enough to mold [to you]." Plus, users who preferred firm beds gave the brand high praise for its firm yet not too firm feel.

Note that each mattress is made-to-order and can take longer to arrive, but many owners told us it was worth the wait.

Who it's best for: Anyone looking to splurge on a luxurious pillow-top mattress and in-store shoppers who want to try out the model in person before purchasing.

Who should avoid it: Those hesitant to splurge on a mattress. If you're unsure about the high price point, we recommended the Estate mattress. It doesn't offer as much pressure relief but affords the same support for $1,000 less.

This Euro-top mattress has an indulgent feel that made our testers want to stay in bed all day long. It comes in a medium firmness and, most importantly, a competitive price point compared to similar models you'll see both online and in-store. While it's not as tall as other mattresses on our list, this makes it a better candidate for using on an adjustable bed base. Plus, it's got an ergonomic layout for targeted support, thanks to the zoned coils.

Tester notes: Sleepy's and Sealy are both popular amongst our panelists, and many appreciate just how fast Mattress Firm is when it comes to delivery and mattress removal. Our most recent tester for this bed said, "I never felt any pressure on my hips or shoulders when lying on my side.” She also shared that it felt so comfortable she "[couldn't] wait to return to it night after night." Still, because of the thick, cushioned pillow-top, she found the edge support lacking compared her previous pillow-top mattress.

Who it's best for: Pillow-top lovers and users looking for added pressure relief. The medium firmness works well for most sleep positions.

Who should avoid it: Shoppers who prefer a taller bed, as this one is on the shorter side, and those who want solid edge support.

Saatva's Classic Mattress is one of the best we've ever tested. You can pick between two heights and three levels of firmness, and the brand will deliver it to your home (and remove your old mattress) at no additional cost. Not only does the Euro-top mattress provide top-notch support without compromising on comfort, but it's also got lofty padding and, best of all, a generous 365-day sleep trial. Just note that you'll have to pay a $99 pickup fee if you decide to return it.

Tester notes: This mattress has earned glowing feedback from our consumer panel. Many have highlighted both the overall comfort and support and the exceptional customer service. When our testers and experts tried out this model, we found the edge support exceptional. Others agreed, with many long-term users sharing how easy it is to get in and out of bed.

Who it's best for: Pillow-top lovers who prefer a little extra support and firmness.

Who should avoid it: Users who prefer a soft, plush pillow-top mattress; this bed may feel too firm for their liking, according to our testers.

While it's not a true pillow-top mattress, this hybrid option offers a similar cushioned feel, thanks to its substantial quilted top. Beyond that, it offers tailored support where it matters the most, like extra cushioning around the hips and back, due to the five distinct zones within its coil system. While it's a newer release than our other picks, the ergonomic layout has proved effective, earning admiration from our experts.

Tester notes: Many mattresses on the market use some form of zonal support, but Bear's five-zone design performed the best in our tests. One tester called the bed "nothing short of amazing," and several reported notable improvements in sleep quality after swapping to it. Another shared, "I suffer from back pain and with this mattress, I wake up pain-free."

Note that Bear makes some recovery-related claims that we couldn't verify in our research, but we still stand behind the mattress for its exceptional comfort.

Who it's best for: Side and back sleepers, users suffering from back pain and those who have struggled to find a truly comfortable mattress.

Who should avoid it: Users looking for a more traditional pillow-top mattress with ample padding.

Compared to the other pillow-top mattresses on our list, the Avocado Green Mattress uses resilient latex in place of foam. This results in a bouncy texture that allows for a floating-like feel, as it contours to your body without sinking in. The bed is also certified organic by the Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS) and the Global Organic Textiles Standard (GOTS), which ensures the entire manufacturing process adheres to strict guidelines.

Tester notes: This mattress proves that you don't need to sacrifice comfort when opting for a more sustainable option. It earned high praise from our testers for its comfort, and several have commended it for how well it has lasted over the years without any dips or indents. There's also a generous year-long trial period to give you plenty of time to decide if it's right for you. Just note that you'll need to pay $600 – $700 extra if you prefer plush to medium firmness.

Who it's best for: Shoppers looking to avoid memory foam, eco-conscious consumers or anyone who likes the springy feel of latex.

Who should avoid it: Those who prefer more cushioning and padding. Latex has a dense, bouncy feel.

If you suffer from chronic back or hip pain, choosing the right mattress for proper spinal alignment is essential. Nolah's mattresses have received copious amounts of praise from dozens of our testers and panel members, including many with joint pain, thanks to its pressure-relieving foam. This model is the brand's most popular and combines several layers of foam over zoned coils, which are designed to cradle your pressure points and promote alignment.

Tester notes: While there's no easy fix for any kind of joint pain, we've received positive feedback from dozens of people with chronic pain. Many have told us the bed made all the difference, stating that it "cushions pressure points" without sinking in too much and conforms nicely to their bodies. One user shared that after having on-and-off back pain for more than 20 years, she hasn't experienced any during the first year of sleeping on this mattress.

Note that the 15-inch profile can be a bit tall for some users and results in a heavy mattress, which can make the DIY setup challenging.

Who it's made for: Users struggling with back pain, hip pain, pregnancy-related pain and sciatica or anyone in search of a little more pressure relief.

Who should avoid it: Anyone looking to avoid a foam-heavy feel (this one has many layers) or who wants a firmer bed. Some users said it runs soft.