1
Affordable Gift
I See Me! God Loves [Insert Name Here]
Credit: Amazon
On their baptism day, you might as well shout this message from the rooftops. If that's not your style, gift them this personalized book about God's love and grace, instead.
2
Personalized Gift
CompanyTwentySix Monogram Quilt
Credit: Etsy
This cotton quilt is made for a baby's nursery with soft scalloped edges and embroidered initials.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3
Best-seller
LAminiJewelry Cross Pearl Bracelet
Credit: Etsy
She'll always treasure her first piece of jewelry, but this delicate Swarovski pearls and gold-filled cross bracelet will make for an extra special memory.
4
Personalized Gift
ClareyClayworks Baptism Bowl
Credit: Etsy
Make the baptism itself even more personal with this clay baptismal water bowl. Once the ceremony is over, the bowl is pretty enough to be left on display or tucked away with the baby's christening gown.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5
Godparent Gift
SweetBellaStationery Godmother Onesie
Credit: Etsy
Wear a pastel pink dress to the party for the ultimate post-baptism photo op. Depending on the season, you can get this adorable onesie with long or short sleeves.
6
Fast Shipping
Simon & Schuster Baby's First Bible
Credit: Amazon
Not quite the level of the King James Version, this starter bible is a kid-friendly way to introduce them to Jesus' story from creation to resurrection.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7
Personalized Gift
LynettePerryDesigns Baptism Wreath Ornament
Credit: Etsy
Start a new tradition by customizing one of these ornaments for their baptism, first communion, and confirmation for a well-dressed tree.
8
Personalized Gift
DolceHome Personalized Wooden Cross
Credit: Etsy
Place this wooden cross on a shelf in the baby's nursery as a permanent reminder of God's unwavering love.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9
Personalized Gift
Susabellas Keepsake Box
Credit: Etsy
Place the baby's first rosary beads or prayer cards in this this earthenware clay box, which is personalized with newborn's name, baptism date, and special symbol. Choose from a shamrock, anchor, heart, cross, olive branch, or star.
10
Personalized Gift
PrintableSky Goddaughter Personalized Print
Customize this print with the newborn's name, baptism date, and the godparents' names. Then print it out and stick it in a frame to display.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11
Nursery Décor
CarrieintheCountry Rustic Scripture Sign
Credit: Etsy
Symbolic of your newborn, this sign is a beautiful reminder that faith — no matter how small — can move mountains.
12
Personalized Gift
ISeeMeBooksUS Thank You, Lord, for Everything
Credit: Etsy
Start 'em young with this customized picture book that reminds your baby (and you!) about all the blessings from God.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13
Best-seller
StampedEve Charm Bracelet
Credit: Etsy
Sweet and simple just like your little one, this sterling silver, gold, or rose gold beaded bracelet comes with three charms: a cross, heart, and circle engraved with the baby's initial.
14
Fast Shipping
Stephan Baby Blankie Lamb
Credit: Amazon
Perfect for post-party cuddles, this ivory Sherpa plush is a stuffed animal and a blanket all in one.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15
From Godparents
BabyboocraftsShop Customized Star
Credit: Etsy
Whether used as nursery décor or a Christmas tree ornament, this wooden star serves as the perfect reminder that you'll always be there to lend a hand, an ear, and most importantly, your heart.
16
Personalized Gift
Pottery Barn Kids Silver Leaf Handprint and Footprint Frame
Credit: Pottery Barn Kids
These statement-making wood frames come with an ink kit to stamp the baby's hand and foot. You also have the option to personalize the prints with the newborn's name and baptism date.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
17
Personalized Gift
FromLucyGifts A Promise To You
Credit: Etsy
With this custom book, make a promise to your baby to love, protect, and celebrate them at their baptism and beyond.
18
Adorable Gift
Pottery Barn Furry Animal Bath Wrap
Now 42% Off
Credit: Pottery Barn KidsParents will use this plush wrap with cotton terry lining every night at bath time and instantly think of you.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19
Best-seller
LifetimeCreations Engraved Baptism Picture Frame
Because Mom and Dad love any excuse to stare at their baby all day. This frame will combine their two greatest loves: their baby and the Lord.
20
Heirloom Quality
Mark and Graham Sterling Silver Baby Brush and Comb
Credit: Mark and Graham
Now that the parents are fully stocked with diapers and onesies, opt for a luxe option fitting for the special occasion: an engraved brush and comb set (for when the baby finally grows some hair, of course).

Amanda Garrity is a lifestyle writer and editor with over seven years of experience, including five years on staff at Good Housekeeping, where she covered all things home and holiday, including the latest interior design trends, inspiring DIY ideas and gift guides for any (and every) occasion. She also has a soft spot for feel-good TV, so you can catch her writing about popular shows like Virgin River, Sweet Magnolias, Hallmark Channel’s When Calls the Heart and more.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below