Skip to Content

30 Easy and Delicious Easter Pies That Your Party Guests Will Love

Chocolate, apple, strawberry, and other fillings you can't resist.

By
Easter Pies
Host the Toast

You know the old saying, "as American as apple pie?" Well, we agree that a piping-hot plate of apple pie certainly lives up to the hype — but there are also so many more flavors of this traditional treat to enjoy. What about a mini lemon meringue pie? Or a slice of cranberry and pear pie? Or even a bite of creamy orange-buttermilk pie? When you think about it, pies are one of the most versatile desserts out there — so you're bound to find something on this list that your whole crowd will enjoy this Easter.

With all of these chocolatey, fruity, and even gluten-free options, your guests definitely won't be looking for any other treats. But just in case, you can always whip up some Easter-themed cookies, cakes, or some of these other desserts for the perfect ending to your Easter party. Just don't expect leftovers, because they'll go quickly. Here are our favorite Easter pie recipes for your most delicious holiday yet.

1

Harvest Pear Blackberry Pie

best easter pies
Mike Garten

As pretty as a picture, guests will enjoy the tart flavoring of the pear and blackberry.

Get the recipe for Harvest Pear Blackberry Pie »

2

Mocha Chocolate Cream Pie

easter pies
Butter Be Ready

You'll be snacking on chocolate all day long, so what's a little more at dessert? This creamy pie can be stored for up to three days in the fridge, meaning the fun can last practically all week.

Get the recipe at Butter Be Ready »

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Strawberry Slab Pie

best easter pies
Brian Woodcock

Cutting out flower-shaped pieces of dough to place on top of these gorgeous strawberries makes a big impact (without a lot of time).

Get the recipe at Country Living »

4

Cranberry-Pear Lattice Pie

easter pies
MIKE GARTEN

Doesn't this look straight out of an old movie? Don't worry, the criss-crossing dough pattern is a lot easier to make than it looks.

Get the recipe for Cranberry-Pear Lattice Pie »

RELATED: 35 Delicious Pie Recipes Anyone Can Make

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Easy Kool-Aid Pie

best easter pies
Grandbaby Cakes

Four ingredients and no bake means you'll have a picture-perfect dessert without any hassel. The best part? You can pick your favorite flavor of Kool-Aid to add!

Get the recipe at Grandbaby Cakes »

6

Salted Caramel Mixed Nut Pie

easter pies
Mike Garten

Your crowd will go nuts for these toasted pecans, walnuts, and hazelnuts held together by sweet caramel.

Get the recipe for Salted Caramel Mixed Nut Pie»

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Lemon Meringue Tartlets

easter pies
MIKE GARTEN

Everyone get a pie to themselves with these bite-sized, tasty tartlets.

Get the recipe for Lemon Meringue Tartlets »

RELATED: 38 Easter Treats You Should Hop to Make Right Now

8

Ganache Tart With Salted-Almond Crust

easter pies
Con Poulos

Technically, ganache isn't pie. But with this salty, dark chocolate taste, we don't think your guests will mind.

Get the recipe for Ganache Tart with Salted-Almond Crust »

RELATED: 17 Bunny-Shaped Treats for Easter

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

Apple Pie With Cheddar Crust

easter pies
MIKE GARTEN

The unexpected sharp grated Cheddar cheese crust creates an amazing sweet and savory taste.

Get the recipe for Apple Pie with Cheddar Crust »

10

Sparkly Apple Slab Pie

easter pies
mike garten

Feeding a crowd? It super easy to parcel out the sheet pan pie.

Get the recipe for Sparkly Apple Slab Pie »

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11

Orange-Buttermilk Chess Pie

easter pies
Romulo Yanes

Candied orange slices and creamy buttermilk come together in this gorgeous pie that's perfect for springtime.

Get the recipe for Orange-Buttermilk Chess Pie »

12

Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Fudge Pie

easter pies
Johnny Miller

All your favorite Easter candy flavors — chocolate, caramel, and peanut butter — come together in this delicious creation.

Get the recipe for Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Fudge Pie »

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13

Very Berry Apple Pie

easter pies
Mike Garten

This gorgeous treat balances tart cranberry flavors with sweet apples and cherries, and the end result is simply magical.

Get the recipe for Very Berry Apple Pie »

14

Decadent Chocolate Espresso Pie

easter pies

Chocolate and coffee and more chocolate, this pie is the ultimate dessert for your guests.

Get the recipe for Decadent Chocolate Espresso Pie »

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15

Honey Lemon Chiffon Pie

easter pies
Courtesy of Host the Toast

From the braided crust to the honeycomb pattern to the little bees made with almond slivers and chocolate, we're buzzing over this gorgeous springtime pie.

Get the recipe from Host the Toast »

16

Mississippi Mud Pie

easter pies

Made with chocolate custard, vanilla ice cream, and fudge sauce, this sweet is pretty much an ice cream sundae in pie form, and we couldn't be more excited to dig in.

Get the recipe for Mississippi Mud Pie »

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
17

Pear Crumb Pie

easter pies
Romulo Yanes

With pears, pecans, toasted oats, and plenty of brown sugar, there's nothing we don't love about this crumbly creation.

Get the recipe for Pear Crumb Pie »

18

Frozen Key Lime Pie on a Stick

easter pies
Christina Lane

The easiest way to make a delicious dessert even better? Cover it in chocolate and put it on a stick, obviously.

Get the recipe for Frozen Key Lime Pie on a Stick »

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19

Cheddar Apple Pie

easter pies
Andrew Purcell

The sharp flavor of the cheddar and the sweetness of the apples and brown sugar all go together beautifully in this pie.

Get the recipe from Country Living »

20

Shaker Lemon Pie

easter pies
MARCUS NILSSON

It doesn't get easier than this classic pie which requires only four ingredients and is sure to please the whole crowd.

Get the recipe from Country Living »

Watch Next 
Easter Pies
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below