Our Editors Tested Amazon's Most Popular Summer Dresses — Here's Our Honest Review

Overall style: 9

• I was wildly impressed by this dress. Despite its sophisticated style, this dress feels like you're wearing pajamas. I wore it on a plane to Florida and it kept me cool and comfortable during my trip. I would recommend this dress to anyone in need of a versatile basic that they can wear to the office, on vacation and beyond. My only note? I wish it had pockets!

Sizing accuracy: 7

• Reviews say that it runs large, so I sized down and it fit like a glove. I'm around 5'5", and it almost grazed the floor with flat shoes. The neckline wasn't too revealing for my larger chest, and the straps are wide enough to conceal a bra.

Fabric quality: 9

• "The fabric is buttery-soft and lightweight without being see-through."

Overall style: 8

• "I love how flowy and lightweight this dress is," says Commerce Editor Anvita Reddy. "I also love that you can dress it up or down. Overall, for the price point, I recommend getting this dress if you're looking for something versatile, comfortable, and affordable for the summer."

Sizing accuracy: 9

• Adjustable features make this dress's sizing more forgiving. "Thanks to its tie straps and stretchy elasticated ruching at the bust area, I could adjust accordingly for a perfect fit. I'm 5'1 with a bigger bust so those two features played a part in how well this dress fit me."

Fabric quality: 7

• "Although the fabric is on the thinner side, it's perfect for hot summer days — but it's not comparable to higher-end nap dresses in terms of fabric quality."

Overall style: 7

• "This Amazon dress is going to be great for summer when I need to throw on something a little bit dressier than shorts, or if I just feel like wearing a breezy dress," says Commerce Editor Jessica Dukes. "Of course, the main attraction is that it has pockets."

Sizing accuracy: 10

• This dress's fit is true to size. "I’ve washed and dried it and it still looks and feels the same," says Dukes.

Fabric quality: 6

• "It's very lightweight which gives it a good flow, and the waistband is stretchy and doesn’t pinch at all. My only advice with this dress is that, because it’s so lightweight, you’ll need a smooth bra and underwear, otherwise you’ll see the lines."

Overall style: 8

• "There’s nothing I love more than a breezy maxi dress in the summer!" says Commerce Editor Madison McGee. "The pattern is adorable and the skirt is flowy without feeling too dramatic."

Sizing accuracy: 9

• "I’m typically between a medium and large in styles like this. I went with a medium and thought it was the perfect length with plenty of room to breathe — if I had gone with a large, I think the fabric would have felt too heavy and overwhelming. I really liked how the one-shoulder bow detail was fully adjustable, especially since I have a larger chest."

Fabric quality: 6

• "My one qualm is that the fabric doesn’t offer that breathable quality I prefer for hot New York City summers, which means this will likely only be a dress I pack for trips to the beach."

Overall style: 8

• "This dress is exactly as pictured — I'm pleasantly surprised!" says Senior Commerce Manager Mackenzie Dunn. "You can opt to wear the straps off the shoulder or on, which is a nice touch. I appreciate the feminine sweetheart neckline that can be tied or left undone. Overall, this is a cute, casual and flattering dress for summer."

Sizing accuracy: 9

• "I'm 5'7” and I was initially worried about the length, but it's not too short on me. The elastic under the bust is stretchy, and the straps also have elastic for comfort that doesn't dig in."

Fabric quality: 5

• "The fabric is lightweight and breathable for summer, and the silhouette is both flattering and extremely comfy." She adds, "I was also concerned that because it is unlined, it may be see-through — but the dark green color did not have that issue."

Overall style: 8

• "I appreciate the casual and easy fit of this wraparound dress, and the color is bright and fun," says Commerce Editor Angel Madison.

Sizing accuracy: 7

• This style is a bit trickier than others. "The ruffled bottom is flirty, but because of the uneven hemline, it was shorter than expected. I thought it would be a bit longer, as I’m only 5’4” and it hit more mid-thigh. I felt more comfortable wearing shapewear shorts underneath, which was helpful on a windy day." She adds, "My biggest issue was with the top. I wear an F cup, and there was a lot of gaping — so much so that I had to pin it in place or wear a tank under it to avoid showing off too much cleavage. I think for a smaller cup size this wouldn’t be an issue."

Fabric quality: 7

• "The fabric has a little bit of stretch, so it is super forgiving," though it's not supremely luxe.

Overall style: 7

• This dress is so much fun for summer! The first thing I noticed was the color, which is just as bright — if not even brighter — in person. The overall fit matches the online picture perfectly. The puff sleeves are an adorable detail, and you can even wear them off-the-shoulder. Plus, I appreciate that the keyhole cutout helps to eliminate boob sweat.

Sizing accuracy: 7

• Per reviews, I went with my usual size, but I could have sized down for more chest support.

Fabric quality: 6

• I like that the skirt has an inner lining, giving it a nice flow. The only major downside was the fabric, which looks and feels cheap. Still, it's is a decent option if you're looking for an affordable dress that looks good in pictures.

Overall style: 6

• "Overall, I was kind-of disappointed by this dress," says Commerce Editor Samantha Jones. "In a pinch, you can definitely make this dress work, but it lacks the overall quality I was hoping for — considering it's the priciest option we tested."

Sizing accuracy: 8

• "The overall fit and silhouette was cute, but I worry about it shrinking in the wash or getting stretched out over time.

Fabric quality: 2

• "Despite the $50 price point, I found the fabric to be stiff and rather cheap — not to mention very see-through. If you order the white color, you'll definitely need to wear something underneath!"